deviant art





Login
Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour Lost Password?
Deviant Login
Shop
 Join deviantART for FREE Take the Tour
About Me Deviant Premium Member shartmanMale/United States Recent Activity
Deviant for 5 Years
8 Month Premium Membership
Statistics 80 Deviations 1,186 Comments 55,868 Pageviews

Watchers



I did not produce the artwork above. It's an absolute classic by the legendary Charles Knight, and it also graced the cover of one of Steven J. Gould's books, "Bully for Brontosaurus". It's lovely, but it also shows off an idea that has been roundly discredited for close to 40 years - the swamp-bound sauropod that needed water to support its weight.

Alas, the BBC is now "reporting" on a "study" that suggests that all large dinosaurs actually had to live in water. Except there isn't a real study. It's not in a paleo journal, and the non-scientist who wrote it didn't present any actual evidence for the idea. But that didn't stop BBC Radio 4 from doing an interview with him, which was then picked up and carried by several print news sources.

It gets worse; the BBC, referring to skepticism expressed for this clown's pseudo-published dataless idea was to invoke Galileo - the scientist who was opposed by non-scientists because his findings were considered heretical.

What The Hell.

If you want to learn more you can check it out on my blog: [link]

Hopefully reputable news outlets will stop publishing tripe so we can all get back to discussing dinosaur anatomy and art like I'd prefer.

Sigh...

deviantID

*shartman
Scott Hartman
United States
Current Residence: Wisconsin
Favourite genre of music: Anything but country...
Operating System: Windows 7
MP3 player of choice: iPod touch till I can get my hands on an Android PMP
Interests

Comments


:icon:
Add a Comment:
 
:iconpaleo-reptiles:
T.rex of this Iranian artist is very like to T.rex of Vlad Konstantinov :
[link]

[link]

[link]
Reply
:iconpaleo-reptiles:
Dear Nima.
There is web of Iranian paleo artist. unfortunatly, he did not pay attention to my scientific advices. also, he should not copy drawing of other artists. What is your opinion?
[link]
Reply
:iconshartman:
I should add that I'm happy to see the website of an Iranian paleo artist - we don't get to see much paleo art out of Iran in this part of the world, and I think it's great to see new artists from new places.

--
Please check out my website [link] or blog [link] for more of the science behind drawing dinosaurs!
Reply
:iconshartman:
I'm afraid I don't totally understand your question - I like Nima. I agree with you that people shouldn't copy other artists and claim it's their own work, but for new artists starting out trying to imitate someone else's style can be an important learning experience - just don't try to turn those pieces into commercial artwork.

--
Please check out my website [link] or blog [link] for more of the science behind drawing dinosaurs!
Reply
:iconpaleo-reptiles:
Stegosaurus of Paul is very different of your stegosaurus. Why? which one of them are correct?
[link]
Reply
:iconshartman:
Obviously mine is ;) Actually, there is some question as to how many species of stegosaur are in the Morrison Formation (and whether they co-existed or are an evolutionary sequence) so it's possible they are both correct; my stegosaur is based on specimens found at Western Paleo, while Greg restored specimens at the Smithsonian and the AMNH.

--
Please check out my website [link] or blog [link] for more of the science behind drawing dinosaurs!
Reply
:iconpaleo-reptiles:
what is your opinion about this Triceratops(specially scales in back)?

[link]
Reply
:iconshartman:
I think it's perfectly plausible - I've seen several photos and casts of the skin impressions and the bottom of the neck (and presumably the stomach) were definitely covered with those big rectangular scales that look like something out of a 1950's B movie.

The Psittacosaur tail spines are possible, although there's no direct evidence for them in Triceratops, and there's a lot of time between the two for them to have changed.

--
Please check out my website [link] or blog [link] for more of the science behind drawing dinosaurs!
Reply
:iconteratophoneus:
Hey scott, I wanted to know if my reconstruction of tyrannotitan is correct. [link]
I am asking you because in terms of anatomy you seem to be a real expert, and I dont know if everything is correct so it would be nice if you could take a look at it.

--
Die Gegenwart ist der Schlüssel zur Vergangenheit- ein Grundsatz der Paläontologie.
Reply
:iconshartman:
Not trying to avoid answering, but I haven't worked over Tyrannotitan and I don't trust current restorations, so I don't really have a useful answer for you. In general I expect it to be quite like Giganotosaurus thought.

--
Please check out my website [link] or blog [link] for more of the science behind drawing dinosaurs!
Reply
:icon:
Add a Comment: